Although the IRS has numerous programs to assist taxpayers in settling outstanding tax debts, deciding which option to use is not always an easy task. Very specific acceptance criteria must be met in order for an application for tax relief to have any chance of being accepted. In addition, the process of filing the initial paperwork and documentation and following up by submitting the required responses to communication from the IRS can be lengthy and challenging. During the time a tax settlement application is under consideration, interest and penalties can accrue. If the settlement offer is then rejected, not only has there been a waste of time and energy on the part of the taxpayer, but the actual amount of the tax debt may have increased making the taxpayer’s financial situation worse.
Below is the detail of an interesting IRS Tax Court case in which the IRS Appeals Office failed to grant a taxpayer’s request for tax debt relief. The case is interesting because it highlights a number of the potential filing problems described in the preceding paragraph. Susan Fay Mostafa, the taxpayer in question, neglected to verify that she met the acceptance criteria for the type of tax debt assistance she was requesting. Her initial error was then compounded when she failed to file a formal request for tax relief on the correct IRS form and then did not respond to several official IRS letters and notices in an appropriate and timely manner.
The Case of Susan Fay Mostafa
• She received an IRS Notice of Deficiency for $1377 for a 1996 tax return that had not been filed. The notice stated that she was also liable for a 25% failure to file penalty.
• Although she submitted a Tax Court petition to challenge the deficiency notice, she later received an IRS notice of Intent to Levy.
• She then challenged the proposed levy by requesting a hearing with the IRS Appeals Office.
• At the same time, she wrote a check to the IRS for $701 and wrote on the check that endorsing it would mean accepting the 1996 tax return as Paid in Full.
• Once the amount of the check was credited to her account, she spoke with the appeals officer several times indicating that she considered her case closed since the IRS had cashed her check.
• In spite of the payment and the subsequent communication, the IRS Tax Court ruled against her.
• After considering all of the trial evidence, the Court of Appeals argued that she had not followed the specific IRS procedures for submitting an Offer in Compromise and had not received either an IRS letter or an IRS notice indicating that such an offer had been accepted.
The Tax Court case outlined above clearly shows that the assistance of a qualified tax settlement specialist may be helpful when submitting an application for tax debt assistance to the IRS. Each year many taxpayers who truly meet the qualification criteria for specific IRS tax relief programs have their applications rejected for one or more of the following reasons:
• failure to meet the acceptance criteria for a selected settlement option
• failure to file a request for assistance using the correct IRS form(s)
• failure to complete the required IRS form(s)correctly
• failure to provide all of the necessary supporting documentation
• failure to conform to the IRS time constraints for submitting forms and documentation
• failure to respond to formal IRS letters and notices in an appropriate and timely manner
Susan Fay Mostafa made all of the above errors when she tried to resolve her tax debt situation without the assistance of a qualified tax specialist. When the IRS Tax Court denied her appeal, she was no better off than she had been when she submitted her initial Tax Court petition. Had she enlisted the help of a tax professional, it would have been that person’s job to adequately document her inability to pay the full amount of her tax debt. Following that, it would have been the specialist’s responsibility to submit the request for relief with the accompanying documentation, to respond to follow-up communication from the IRS in an appropriate and timely manner and to advocate for Ms. Mostafa before the United States Tax Court.
The bottom line is not to try to handle a complex tax settlement case alone. Hire the right professional to help you achieve tax debt relief. Visit www.professinoaltaxresolution.com for more information about tax settlement options and contact us today at (949)-596-4143 or info@protaxres.com to receive a free, no obligation consultation.
