With credit so tight and banks unwilling to loan to small businesses and individuals, more and more family members are faced with the difficult decision of how or when to help out. Once you decide to lend a hand, you have to consider the potential tax implications. You ask yourself would it be better to make an outright gift or to make a loan with the expectation of repayment?
Let’s consider the scenario of a gift.
Many people are aware that small cash gifts generally don’t have to be reported to IRS. However, you should also keep in mind that if you give more than $13,000 in a single year to an individual it still needs to be reported on a gift tax return, and this could have an effect on your general estate situation.
But, wait are there not new estate tax rules that would protect you from a tax standpoint? The answer is Yes and No. The 2010 Tax Act provides everyone a $5 million lifetime exemption for estate and gift transfers. However, it does not exclude you from having to report a gift to an individual when it exceeds $13,000 in one year.
Why you might ask? The generous $5 million lifetime exemption is only on the books until Dec. 31, 2012 and many tax professionals dread the potential for a “claw back” which may in fact happen after the 2012 cut off considering the sorry state of our economy. What a ‘claw back” could mean is that all of the reportable gifts you made during your lifetime could be considered having actually occurred in your estate after 2012 – regardless of how much exemption Congress will allow after next year. The bottom line is you can’t assume that the IRS will not monitor your gift transfers in the months ahead even though you don’t have any tax liability right now.
So, now let’s consider a Loan.
Is it advantageous to treat your monetary support as a loan rather than an outright gift? A properly documented loan will show the IRS that you did not intend to make a reportable gift and will also clarify the repayment expectations with whomever you are helping. But perhaps most importantly for you, certain tax reporting issues can be easily eliminated with the documentation of this support having been a loan.
Of course this does not come without caution. The IRS is leery about the legitimacy of loans especially when they’re between family members. So whatever you prepare as loan documentation you must make it clear that it is what is considered an arm’s-length loan and that you expect to be repaid. While you don’t need an attorney to draft up a formal document, it does always help to spell out the payment terms and any interest that you may charge. Even better, you can try to secure collateral to legitimize your loan agreement.
Gosh, how can you even think about charging interest when the person you are helping is faced with a dire financial situation? It is true; most will just try to keep things simple by making an interest-free loan, especially when it involves family. But here is why this is not a great idea for you from a tax standpoint. The IRS really considers that true bona fide loans have a reasonable interest rate charged and paid by the borrower. In fact here is the real rub, if you make an “interest-free” loan over $10,000 to anyone, the IRS will “impute” interest for you, based on rates set by the Treasury. What does that mean? You could wind up paying tax on fictitious interest that you never received! To protect yourself, charge a minimal interest rate for any loan you make.
Ok so now what happens when that Loan fails to be repaid?
Yikes. Well, if you loaned $20,000 or $30,000 to a friend or a relative, you now have a true loss or debt and you might be wishing you some records of that fact. Why you ask? You may now be eligible for an attractive (bad-debt) tax deduction in the year of worthlessness.
But how formal a set of documentation do you need to be able to document this bad-debt deduction? Obviously the more the better, but if you have some written documentation and the transfer of funds was clearly labeled you may be ok. A landmark tax court decision observed that a valid debt may exist without all the legal formalities even when between related parties. In this case, the taxpayer prevailed over the IRS because his intentions were proved with business-like actions and by making informal notations – such as marking “loan” on checks and deposit slips, etc. In this particular case the key was that that taxpayer and the recipient of the loan were recognized as creditable witnesses with a prior debtor-creditor relationship. The bottom line is, do what you can to document and legitimize the loan and consider it and insurance policy for yourself in the future.
This is just one example of the tax advice and guidance we provide each and every day. If you have a loan that has failed to be repaid, a tax debt, unfiled tax returns, or any other tax related problem give us a call for a free, no obligation consultation (877) 889-6527. Talk directly with a CPA and understand what we can do to resolve your tax problem once and for all. Look us up – we are proud A rated members of the BBB.
